You know what's one of the neat effects about running your FLAILSNAILS character through multiple campaign worlds? It becomes crystal clear (from your point of view) who the protagonist of this saga is. It can't be anybody but your PC because the rest of the cast keeps changing. In most rpg campaigns I get a nagging little feeling that the real star is the party (whoever is in it this week) or the setting (if you're playing in that kind of game).
You can go through umpteen PCs and the party somehow remains intact. How many times have you seen a total party kill followed by a totally new group of PCs picking up the adventure right where it left off? Makes my dude-of-the-moment seem a little less grandiose every time that happens, like any old cookie cutter dungeon jerks can finish this all-important quest. And while I like a well-crafted campaign as much as the next guy, a crummy setting pretty much forces the heroes to the forefront.
Speaking of crummy settings: Hyboria. Don't get me wrong here. Those old Conan tales are on the very short list of fantasy fiction I will read. (I honestly don't know how so many of you slog through so much drek in search of the occasional good fantasy novel. Howard. Tolkien. Lovecraft. Vance. Smith. Dunsany. That's the pretty much all of Appendix N that I can stand.) But seriously, Hyboria is a jumbled-up mess of patchwork sections of any nation that ol' Two-Gun Bob wanted to use for the latest Conan romp. Nothing more. And that's why it's effin' brilliant for gaming. Not that we should be running Hyboria. No, no, no. But I think we could do good work emulating it's seat-of-the-pants rip-off-whatever-you-can methodology.
And whaddya know, that's pretty much how FLAILSNAILS operates. I run a little piece of the setting right here. Evan runs another section, totally unrelated to mine, over there. Jeremy runs a third chunk of the multiverse on over there. If you look too closely they don't fit that well together, the way the medieval Aquilonia and sorta-Renaissance Zingara don't really compute in the same setting. But as a backdrop for the adventures of your mighty hero? Works just fine. In fact, you could string together individual sessions in faraway settings the way L. Sprague de Camp introduces each story in the old Ace editions of Conan, with a brief intro paragraph of connective tissue:
Fed up with civilization and its magic, Conan rides back to his native Cimmeria. After a month or two of wenching and drinking, however, he grows restless enough to join his old friends, the Aesir, in a raid into Vanaheim.Or you can keep a log of each adventure, like this crude one I have for my FLAILSNAILS guy Young MacDonnal.
8-10-11 Donnal was 1 of 4 crappy 0-level PCs (3 of 8 total) to survive the canonical DCC intro adventure “The Portal Under the Stars”. DM: Shawn Sanford (arcadayn). Fellow players: Zak S. Looted the weapons and armor of the War-Wizard.There's nothing particularly special about this little twerp of a fighter 2. Seriously, his only bonus in life is a Charisma of fifteen. There are better PCs out there. And guys with a lot more kickass adventures under their belt. We're basically all treading jeweled thrones under our feet. So do yourself a solid and savor this stuff. It's not about the party. It's not about some quest. It sure as hell ain't about the setting. FLAILSNAILS is all about [your PC's name here].
11-19-11 Donnal adventured briefly with Zaunn the Mighty (Niles Calder), Redwall the Thief (now Boner the Pig, Jeremy Deram), Agnes the Amazon (?). Visited Nightwick Abbey (Evan van Elkins) for about 10 minutes before DMs internet went out. Donnal refuses to discuss what happened that fateful day.
1-10-12 - Stan [Donnal's henchman] begins adventuring with Donnal. Sold mithral from 1st adventure to a sage in Jeremy Deram’s Outland. Adventured with Blixa the Thief & Abe (Zak S), Steve Albertson’s Tengu thief Scarecrow Hooker & his henchman the dwarf Barkbeard Woodsack, Kyrinn Eis of Urutsk's 0-level troupe (Doc Sampson, alchemist; Ozzy Sweetleaf, goblin glassblower/astrologer; John Plisskin, carpenter; Hell Tanner, tanner). Ransacked the Mysterious Cave Epsilon. Gained pet psionic lizard guy.
Howard. Tolkien. Lovecraft. Vance. Smith. Dunsany.
ReplyDeleteI notice a disturbing lack of Leiber, but otherwise that's pretty much my list too.
This post is also 100% accurate.
Those old Conan tales are on the very short list of fantasy fiction I will read. (I honestly don't know how so many of you slog through so much drek in search of the occasional good fantasy novel...)
ReplyDeleteWow, and here I thought I was the only one! Glad to know I'm in good company. We should start a "Fantasy Gamers Who Don't Read Fantasy Literature" book club.
I'm in, in fact I will pony up a year's dues in advance. I've been reading just about anything but fantasy--ironically just after reading through the whole REH Conan cycle again--these days.
DeleteWhat you say about pulp novels goes for all hobbies (including this one).
ReplyDeleteEverybody likes to catch a fish.
A fisherman is someone willing to spend hours _not_ catching a fish so he can catch a fish.
Everybody likes good music.
A record collector is someone who is willing to spend hours listening to _bad_ music in case some of it is good.
(Wraethu report anyone?)
Anyway yeah, this whole post is good.
@sirlarkins Sign me up for the "Fantasy Gamers Who Don't Read Fantasy Literature" book club!
ReplyDelete"It sure as hell ain't about the setting."
ReplyDeleteI think I have to politely disagree, though I agree with a lot of the enthusiasm of the post.
A great big part of the fun for me is the exploring of each person's world. I enjoyed Evan's game for the chance to play in the Nightwick Abbey I've read about for months, yours for Wessex and so on down the road.
I like the particular quirks of each world, the flavor of each bit and the peculiar emphasis on this or that house rule.
I can read Howard and Lovecraft, each in controlled doses (Howard writes great action; ever try his boxing stories?). I've read a fair chunk of Dunsany though I don't recall how I did it. I was motivated to better understand who Lovecraft desperately wanted to be (same reason I read Poe).
ReplyDeleteI can't slog through Tolkien, Vance, or Smith, though I've tried (exception: I like the Hobbit, but my attempts to wade through LotR have always failed due to utter boredom ... and it's always Helm's Deep where I fail. I get that far, and in the middle of the battle scene, I give up).
The only fantasy novelist I've ever really loved is Barry Hughart, though.
In the ending notes in Uresia2, I spend some time yabbering about how, having never had LotR to provide a platonic ideal of fantasy, I depend on things like Zork, Groo, old TSR gameworlds and games of Talisman 2nd Edition to define what fantasy means to me, for better or worse.
Speaking of crummy settings: Hyboria. Don't get me wrong here. Those old Conan tales are on the very short list of fantasy fiction I will read. (I honestly don't know how so many of you slog through so much drek in search of the occasional good fantasy novel. Howard. Tolkien. Lovecraft. Vance. Smith. Dunsany. That's the pretty much all of Appendix N that I can stand.) But seriously, Hyboria is a jumbled-up mess of patchwork sections of any nation that ol' Two-Gun Bob wanted to use for the latest Conan romp. Nothing more. And that's why it's effin' brilliant for gaming. Not that we should be running Hyboria. No, no, no. But I think we could do good work emulating it's seat-of-the-pants rip-off-whatever-you-can methodology.
ReplyDeleteAmen.
Interesting how everyone latched onto the offhand literature comment.
ReplyDeleteI will say that Boner is one of the lamest PCs I've ever had, and he's also my favorite.