So we discovered some things about playing T&T instead of D&D.
The slightly more abstracted combat system (where you don't roll initiative and you don't target specific baddies most of the time and to-hit & damage are merged into a signle throw) is too little player interaction for some tastes. Sure, the Saving Throw mechanic (which is also the skill system and the 'do everything else' mechanic) is wide-open, but the simple act of beating mooks up seemed less satisfactory than baseline D&D. At least to these players.
The spells with the stupid names ("Take That You Fiend", etc.) that turn off so many people were a big hit, both for the names and what they do. The first level wizard especially enjoyed summoning up some skeletons. They weren't that hot in combat but they absorbed some blows intended for the PCs.
Also, I think my one page, one line per spell handout really helped. I ought to do that for my D&D games. As soon as I finish my custom spell list. Have I mentioned here I've got about 160 spells in a draft google doc, based upon completely scrapping the present D&D list (but not mechanics) and going with spells powered by invoking angels and demons? Here's a randomly selected entry:
I'm currently working on adding spells based upon the demons in the Pseudomonarchia Daemonum, a 16th century work listing infernal dudes that can be invoked. But now I'm left wondering if maybe my players would prefer less showboaty book-learning based spells and more Take That You Fiend.Yellow Ray of Iophiel - power: Iophiel - party: heaven - level: 2 - magical light, bullseye lantern in dimensions, sunlight illumination, lasts 12 turns - d6 damage per round against vampires, etc. blinds and possibly routes nocturnal monsters such as orcs
Another thing that I discovered is that rolling 5d6+20 for each of four or five monsters gets to be a pain in the ass after a while, even though I can roll it all at once as 25d6+100. Carl and Charles, being computer science guys, spent some of the time I was rolling and adding discussing the technical details of how the players can total their side's attack in parallel versus the serial approach of the GM.
7th edition T&T introduces a concept called Spite Damage. In previous editions the side with the lower combat total took damage equal to the differences between the two attack totals. Spite Damage is where every 6 rolled on a die indicates a point of damage is inflicted no matter which side wins and that damage ignores armor. I can see why the mechanic was developed, but I'm not sure whether I like it or not. I do enjoy all the monsters in the 7th edition monster pamphlet that have some sort of subsitute to Spite. As an example, a medusa might get off a gaze attack only when it rolls at least 2 sixes in combat. Or a chimera might only breath fire on 3 sixes. It's an interesting concept whereby some monster behavior is random, somewhat akin to my Stupid Dracula Tricks chart.
Another thing that I like is that different weapons and armor are rated for Str and/or Dex required to use it. You can wield a weapon that's too heavy for you, but it makes you tired (you lose Str equal to the amount you're short to qualify). Traveller also uses these minima to great effect and Empire of the Petal Throne requires a certain Str rating to use various two-handed weapons. Maybe I could put variable damage back into my game if I used a similar system. One has to be careful when setting the mins, though. As it stands in T&T 7th and ordinary Broadsword has a Str min of 15, meaning most starting warrior types won't qualify to use it without penalty. I'm not sure I dig on that.
Anyways, the game itself was a pretty good time. Traps were activated. Giant snakes, trolls, vampires, orcs and batwinged toadmonsters were all defeated. The party members scored over 500gp apiece in loot. And one of Carl's Welsh bowmen put on a magic ring that turned him into a vampire. At first we considered ignoring that item for continuity purposes. But then I decided we'd turn that call over to the dice. The roll said his PC will continue to be a vampire in the D&D campaign. I can't wait to see how that turns out.