Folks recommended some non-D&D systems for this campaign concept. Pendragon, Chivalry & Sorcery and Ars Magica were mentioned. Personally I think HarnMaster, MERP and Bruce Galloway's Fantasy Wargaming would also be pretty good options. However, the genesis of the campaign concept was an attempt to fish around for an interesting period to run a more historical version of D&D, so if I got this baby off the ground it would probably be with Labyrinth Lord or one of the umpteen other versions I own. Though whichever D&D I went with would be hacked up a bit. Platemail would get the boot as it is inappropriate to the period. Magic-Users would probably be tarted up a bit to put conjuring demons front and center. And the Cleric as a class would be gone. Period. Most members of the priestly caste would be Normal Men, except for those Bishop Odo types who go about kicking ass as Fighting Men and the sketchy scholars practicing Magic-Use.
Gameblog reader cr0m asks a key question about the campaign concept:
What do you imagine the characters doing? Fighting in the political struggle, dungeon exploration, or something entirely different?I can't run Dungeons & Dragons without having some dungeons in the mix. For a more historical type game, I think I would hide most of the crazier monsters there. I don't mind having fairy tale type stuff like dragons and unicorns on the hex map, but the flumphs and gorbels would definitely stay in the crazy ass underworld environ. Basically the idea would be to play the campaign fairly straight on the surface, but cut loose with my usual wild self once the PCs go down the steps to Level One. Sure, that means that at some point one of the players will try to change the course of British history with a laser rifle they pried out of the cold dead hands of a cyberbalrog inexplicably dressed like Pee-Wee Herman, but that's just the way it goes sometimes.
Seeing the PCs participates in the vast fiasco that is the Anarchy would be nice, so I hope they would get swept up in historical events. Though they may not entirely like the results of such intrigue, as I tend to imagine that it would go about as well as Clint Eastwood and Tuco's encounters with the U.S. Civil War in The Good, the Bad and the Ugly.