I love that map, and I kind of really like the original version PotSP that it comes from - even a bit more than the "fixed" Moldvay version (heresy). The setting of the adventure feels more like "dark fairy tale" than anything else, which gives it a different feel from the Sword and Sorcery or the Epic Fantasy stuff that TSR tended to publish for D&D. The actual dungeon crawl portion is kind of meh - but then I've always felt that the lower level of PotSP was kind of meh, even in the somewhat better Moldvay version of the adventure (the upper level in the Moldvay version is pretty good, IIRC, but the lower dungeon is just kind of boring). But the wilderness area, for all of its oddities, feels like twisted fairy tale, and I like that a lot.
I gotta agree with Jer that, ultimately, the original "flawed" Wells version is just better than the Moldvay version. Or perhaps I should say that both authors seem to have been given a premise, and wrote different adventures based on that, and I vastly prefer Wells' ideas.
I popped in here to say that I prefer the Wells version, only to discover everyone else saying the same thing! :)
Moldvay's version is certainly more polished -- and it's also a module that I played extensively when I first got into the hobby, so I'm hardly going to slight it.
And Wells' version could certainly use a little more polish. (And I never liked the B1-style of a half-completed module.)
But the ideas Wells was playing with were just fresher than what Moldvay gave us. As Jer says, the "twisted fairy tale" aspect of the module is really interesting. Wells also had far more dynamic and interesting NPCs (whereas Moldvay's rewrite puts everything in far more black-and-white terms). And Wells was also giving us a very classic D&D structure -- an expandable dungeon (with the implication that it was a megadungeon); the seeds for an interesting overland area; and so forth.
I've often said the single best example of the shift in adventure design that occured with TSR (and D&D in general) in the early 80's is to put the two versions of Palace of the Silver Princess next to each other. The orange version epitomizes the old and the green version epitomizes the newer.
Old: messy, open ended, holes to fill, little explanation, massively creative, endlessly playable.
New: clean, closed, ready to play, over-explained, underwhelming, played once and put away.
Oddly, aside from the green version of PotSP, Moldvay's stuff was entirely of the first category instead of the second and among my favorite rpg products ever produced.
I'm reading through the Book of Weird right now, and it occurs to me that this map and the orange cover version of PotSP would be the perfect foundation for a more fairy-tale-esque D&D game.
Somewhere between the Wells free for all and the Moldvay do-over is the perfect version of B3. I really hate "non-niche" monsters that seem to exist only for the purpose of being kooky (the Decapus and Ubue fall into this category for me); however, I'll agree with the sentiment here that the Wells version is more in the "spirit" of basic D&D. I'd love to whip up a redo that incorporates the best of both worlds...
Agents of W.R.E.T.C.H. and Alien Invasions
-
Hello Dear Readers! Today’s blog post is brought to you by the letter V—V
for Visitors. About a week ago, I binge-watched V (2009) reboot. For those
who do...
Crapland is a game. (SPEED-RUN) Session twoo.
-
召喚 by 妖女 · 天火見
✿.。.- ☆-. during this actual play I listened to the album .-.☆-.-。.✿
(catch up on the previous session here)
1.
Shark-8 caries Tela under ...
Goodness Gracious, I've Gone to the Dark Side
-
What with the new 2024 revisions due to start being released this coming
September, I am converting my online game to D&D 5th edition.
I still have to en...
Dungeon Apps
-
"I’ve just been wondering what apps adventurers would use if smartphones
worked in dungeons"
- Jeff Rients
Here's some ideas we had:
"Lock app for th...
Troika! character sheet
-
I made a simple horizontal Troika! character sheet and thought I’d share it
here for free. Hopefully somebody will find it useful! 🙂 Download the
charac...
The Time Bandits
-
Six boisterous dwarves, who, until recently, were employed by the *Supreme
Being* to fix holes in the space-time continuum. Then they had a
brainstorm: W...
Let’s make goblins unique
-
When a goblin is encountered (or a bunch of the nasty beasts), roll a set
of 6 dice (d4, d6, d8, d10, d12, d20) for each of a few of them, or at
least thei...
Philately & Phylacteries: D&D Comes to the USPS
-
If you follow Grognardia as closely as I do, you have no double heard about
the upcoming D&D stamps the United States Postal Service will […] Read More
Numenera: Those Who Move Clouds, Session 1
-
When a Shadow of the Demon Lord campaign I was running came to a close, I
had everyone vote on what would I would run next, from games on The List
(almost ...
cryptid in july poetry day 09, the enfield horror
-
a poem about the enfield horror
I’m an armpit leaping
around the woods on three
legs waiting
for police to arrest me
I’m the living
embodiment of cough...
Übersiedelt
-
Dieser Blog ist Anfang des Jahres 2022 übersiedelt. Am Blog von
gazerpress.at schreibe ich weiterhin über Historisches und Aktuelles rund
ums Rollenspiel.
In Defense of Race As Class
-
Race As Class! Baffling to some, overly simplistic to others, gold to me.
Race As Class does what even AD&D didn't have the balls to do: it not only
says "...
A Fresh Start
-
Morning Folks
I came across someone's blog the other day and I liked it's focus, focus is
something I could use so I'm going to steal it along with anyt...
A timeline for historical games in the Lowlands
-
6th century: Clovis I, King of the Franks, converts to the Roman Church
1000: Pagan Saxon and Frisian religions cease to exist as such and are
subsumed un...
Not the best year
-
In many ways 2021 has not been a lot of fun. For me, it started with
catching COVID-19, along with many of the friends I game with, and while,
fortunately,...
Another Whack at Skills and Classes
-
I have enjoyed running Lamentations of the Flame Princess games regularly
since 2012. Regardless of certain tedious controversies surrounding the
publis...
XP per esplorazione
-
Di recente la blogosfera è stata attraversata da un dibattito su come
assegnare punti esperienza extra oltre il consueto (e rodato) Oro*xp. Già a
suo te...
Blog Reboot
-
How starting over feels...
After the disaster that was 2020 I decided it would be best to start over
on a new blog. Wipe the state clean as they say. It'll...
Vengeful Cuckold and Cuckquean Generator
-
I submitted a table I made to Jeff Rients for his awesome Flame Princess
Cult Zine. I have already used it in several ways during games and have
enjoye...
REVIEW – Fish Fuckers
-
Fish Fuckers is a Lamentations of the Flame Princess Adventure with Text
and Art by Kelvin Green, Graphic Design by Alex Mayo, and Editing by
Jarrett Crade...
Ten Fearsome Pit Fighters of the Grand Arena
-
There are many fighting pits in the city, but none of them compare to the
Grand Arena in terms of prestige, showmanship, and skill of the fighters.
The fig...
Finally, a review!
-
Today, we are taking a look at *Obscene Serpent Religion 2 By *Jeff Rients
for Lamentations of the Flame Princess.
I rate products in these categories:
Writ...
House Rule: (More) Cannon Fodder
-
One issue that people can have with LotFP/OSR games is high character
turnover. Sometimes the module is too deadly, the players too green, the GM
too evil...
You Can't Do That!
-
I remember the light and magic that lit my mind of fire the first time I
played Dungeons and Dragons. My friend had gotten a starter set that had a
great ...
It's a nice map, but it was a weird module to run for my first try as a Labyrinth Lord.
ReplyDeleteI love that map, and I kind of really like the original version PotSP that it comes from - even a bit more than the "fixed" Moldvay version (heresy). The setting of the adventure feels more like "dark fairy tale" than anything else, which gives it a different feel from the Sword and Sorcery or the Epic Fantasy stuff that TSR tended to publish for D&D. The actual dungeon crawl portion is kind of meh - but then I've always felt that the lower level of PotSP was kind of meh, even in the somewhat better Moldvay version of the adventure (the upper level in the Moldvay version is pretty good, IIRC, but the lower dungeon is just kind of boring). But the wilderness area, for all of its oddities, feels like twisted fairy tale, and I like that a lot.
ReplyDeleteI gotta agree with Jer that, ultimately, the original "flawed" Wells version is just better than the Moldvay version. Or perhaps I should say that both authors seem to have been given a premise, and wrote different adventures based on that, and I vastly prefer Wells' ideas.
ReplyDeleteI popped in here to say that I prefer the Wells version, only to discover everyone else saying the same thing! :)
ReplyDeleteMoldvay's version is certainly more polished -- and it's also a module that I played extensively when I first got into the hobby, so I'm hardly going to slight it.
And Wells' version could certainly use a little more polish. (And I never liked the B1-style of a half-completed module.)
But the ideas Wells was playing with were just fresher than what Moldvay gave us. As Jer says, the "twisted fairy tale" aspect of the module is really interesting. Wells also had far more dynamic and interesting NPCs (whereas Moldvay's rewrite puts everything in far more black-and-white terms). And Wells was also giving us a very classic D&D structure -- an expandable dungeon (with the implication that it was a megadungeon); the seeds for an interesting overland area; and so forth.
I've often said the single best example of the shift in adventure design that occured with TSR (and D&D in general) in the early 80's is to put the two versions of Palace of the Silver Princess next to each other. The orange version epitomizes the old and the green version epitomizes the newer.
ReplyDeleteOld: messy, open ended, holes to fill, little explanation, massively creative, endlessly playable.
New: clean, closed, ready to play, over-explained, underwhelming, played once and put away.
Oddly, aside from the green version of PotSP, Moldvay's stuff was entirely of the first category instead of the second and among my favorite rpg products ever produced.
Obviously, I too, prefer the orange to the green.
I'm reading through the Book of Weird right now, and it occurs to me that this map and the orange cover version of PotSP would be the perfect foundation for a more fairy-tale-esque D&D game.
ReplyDeleteSomewhere between the Wells free for all and the Moldvay do-over is the perfect version of B3. I really hate "non-niche" monsters that seem to exist only for the purpose of being kooky (the Decapus and Ubue fall into this category for me); however, I'll agree with the sentiment here that the Wells version is more in the "spirit" of basic D&D. I'd love to whip up a redo that incorporates the best of both worlds...
ReplyDelete